In a somber courtroom scene, Richard Sotka, a Green Bay resident, received two consecutive life sentences without the possibility of release for the brutal stabbing deaths of two women. The tragic incident, which shocked the community, culminated in a verdict that underscored the severity of the crimes and the lasting impact on the victims’ families and loved ones.
Sotka, 49, was also ordered by Brown County Circuit Court Judge Beau Liegeois to make reparation payments exceeding $16,000. The sentencing, handed down on Monday, marked the culmination of a legal process that began after the bodies of Paula O’Connor, 53, of Bellevue, and Rhonda Cegelski, 58, of Green Bay, were discovered in a Green Bay residence in January 2023.
The trial, which concluded in March, saw Sotka convicted on two counts of first-degree intentional murder, along with additional charges related to the deaths of O’Connor and Cegelski. According to a prosecution complaint, Sotka confessed to authorities, admitting that he “snapped” and killed the women after feeling “humiliated” when they laughed at him.
Throughout the proceedings, Sotka maintained his innocence, claiming he acted in self-defense. Despite his assertions, the jury found him guilty, imposing the maximum penalty allowed by law.
In a dramatic courtroom moment, Sotka, who intends to appeal his convictions, addressed the court, asserting, “While everyone wants me to show remorse, I feel nothing.” His lack of contrition further underscored the chilling nature of the crimes and the pain inflicted upon the victims’ families.
The sentencing drew to a close a harrowing chapter for the community, offering some semblance of closure to those impacted by the tragedy. However, the scars left by the senseless violence perpetrated by Sotka are unlikely to heal easily, serving as a stark reminder of the fragility of life and the profound consequences of unchecked anger and violence.
As the families of Paula O’Connor and Rhonda Cegelski continue to grapple with their loss, they find solace in the knowledge that justice has been served. Yet, the void left by their absence remains, a poignant reminder of the preciousness of life and the need to cherish every moment with loved ones.
In the aftermath of this tragedy, the community of Green Bay comes together in solidarity, offering support and compassion to those affected by the loss. Through collective efforts to prevent such senseless acts of violence and promote peace and understanding, the community strives to honor the memories of the two women whose lives were tragically cut short.
